93 points Wine & Spirits
The old vines planted in 1968 at Gravelly Meadow produced a quieter 2011 than Volcanic Hill; it’s saturated with blue and blackberry flavors at a cool moment of ripeness. The wine’s beauty shifts in and out at different moments over the course of several days, sometimes sunny, plum sweet and a little gruff in its tannins, sometimes shadowed and elegant. It feels the most structured of the three Diamond Creek 2011s, at times tough, brisk and precise.
93 points Connoisseurs Guide
The challenge with the trio from Diamond Creek is to array them in some sort of order. They are always close, and, if we prefer one to the other, it is never by much and each of these lovelies could wind up in your cellar and serve you well for years to come. This wine is highlighted by inviting aromas of fresh currants, red fruits and touches of spice and dark soils with a faint cola note. Like its mates, it is medium-full in body, and, here, its tannins are a bit more polished even though equally evident. Optimum balance is achieved by its combination of attractive, energetic pieces rather than from structure alone, and we would expect this one to grow for a decade and more.
94 points Antonio Galloni
The 2011 Cabernet Sauvignon Gravelly Meadow is quite dark and imposing in this vintage. Sweet tobacco, menthol, cloves and mocha form a gorgeous fabric in this deep, supple Cabernet Sauvignon. I won't be surprised if the Gravelly Meadow turns out to be one of the overachievers of the year. There is a lot to like here.
From the winemaker: The 2013 vintage was like a sister to the previous year. A temperate spring led to a nice healthy set. Copious amounts of sunshine and a long,...
Antonio Galloni 91pts: The 2013 Cabernet Sauvignon is dark, fleshy and seductive, but also light on its feet and gracious. Black cherry, plum, rose petal, smoke, tobacco, licorice and cedar...
Vinous 90pts: The 2012 Convexity Cabernet Sauvignon captures the open-knit, racy personality of the vintage in spades. Crushed raspberries, flowers and spices lift from the glass in an attractive, mid-weight...